DC’s controversial saga shows the dark side of superheroes; you know?

The history of superhero comics is full of iconic moments and sagas that shaped the world of publishing. Marvel and DC Comics.

Among them, “Identity Crisis” stands out, a narrative that, due to its dark approach and controversial themes, remains one of the most debated and analyzed by fans and critics.

The 1990s had seen a saturation of superhero titles, many of which sacrificed narrative quality in favor of spectacular action scenes.

Additionally, competition from independent comics and manga was gaining momentum, while Marvel Comics faced financial difficulties that led it to sell the rights to some of its characters.

In this challenging scenario, the DC Comics sought innovation and talent outside of the traditional comics medium, and one of those talents was renowned novelist Brad Meltzer, known for his expertise in police plots and conspiracy theories.

His entry into DC brought new perspectives to the publisher and prepared the ground for the creation of “Identity Crisis”.

The focus on the heroes’ intimacy

Unlike many previous DC Comics sagas, which involved cosmic threats and parallel dimensions, “Identity Crisis” chose a more intimate and dark path.

The plot revolves around a mysterious murder that hits the superheroes’ personal lives hard, starting with the murder of Sue Dibny, Elongated Man’s wife. This event serves as the starting point for a series of dark revelations and unpredictable consequences.

Meltzer and illustrator Rags Morales chose to keep the narrative on Earth, exploring personal details and relationships between characters that were rarely addressed.

This gave the story a more realistic and “down to earth” tone, distancing it from the typical cosmic narratives of the previous sagas.

Dark revelations

One of the main twists in the saga is the revelation that Doctor Luz had raped Sue Dibny in the past. This dark event is revisited when members of the Justice League, including the Green Lantern and Flash argue about how to deal with the villain.

The decision to “lobotomize” Doctor Luz to erase his memories of the heroes’ secret identities triggers a heated ethical debate among the team members.

Image: DC Comics/Reproduction

In relation :  Black Mirror: Netflix announces the arrival of season 6

Batman’s role in this context is particularly interesting, as he opposes the decision of the Justice League, condemning the action of erasing memories. This moment sows future developments in the narrative.

The conclusion of “Identity Crisis” never ceased to surprise readers, although it divided opinions. The revelation that Jean Loring, Eléktron’s wife, was responsible for Sue Dibny’s death had a significant impact.

Jean, seeking to get her husband’s attention, attacked Sue, resulting in her accidental death. The plot also reveals that Jean used technology to simulate a hanging, hiding her guilt.

Lasting consequences

The consequences of “Identity Crisis” have reverberated throughout the years in DC Comics. Characters that were previously considered second-rate, such as Doctor Luz and Terminator, gained greater prominence as villains capable of facing the publisher’s main heroes.

Jean Loring, on the other hand, underwent a dark transformation by becoming a version of Eclipso, introducing an element of corruption into the narrative.

The saga also sparked an era of distrust between the heroes, leading them to confront past issues and reconcile their differences.

Batman, motivated by the lobotomization episode, created the Omac surveillance system, which would play an important role in future stories, culminating in the iconic scene in which the Wonder Woman breaks Maxwell Lord’s neck.

Image: DC Comics/Reproduction

“Identity Crisis” continues to be one of DC Comics’ most controversial sagas, due to its dark approach, disturbing themes and unexpected twists.

Although its conclusion caused controversy, the narrative provided a deeper exploration of the superheroes’ personal lives and their complex relationships.

Its consequences shaped the universe of DC Comics for many years, making her an essential part of superhero mythology.

Ultimately, it serves as an example of how comic books can defy convention and explore deeper aspects of characters, making them richer and more engaging for readers.